The Ultimate Guide to Buying the Perfect Anal Plug for Beginners and Pros

July 18, 2025

Look, we get it. Walking into an adult store can feel awkward enough, but trying to figure out what anal plug you need while someone's breathing down your neck? That's next-level uncomfortable. Thank goodness for online shopping, right? You can browse from your couch in your pajamas without anyone judging your choices.


Here's the thing though - buying best adult toys online comes with its own challenges. You can't touch anything, you're scrolling through endless options, and half the descriptions sound like they were written by robots. That's where this guide comes in handy. We're going to walk you through everything you need to know about choosing an anal plug that'll actually work for you, not against you. No fluff, no weird euphemisms - just straight talk about finding something that'll enhance your pleasure without making you regret your life choices.


What Exactly Are Anal Plugs and Why Do People Love Them?

A variety of anal plugs in different shapes and sizes, encouraging individuals to explore self-care and discover the right adult toy for their needs and comfort.

So you're probably wondering what the big deal is with anal plugs, right? Picture this: they're like the difference between a quick pat on the shoulder and a really good back massage. These toys are designed to sit comfortably in place, creating this amazing sense of fullness that can make everything else feel more intense.

The nerve endings around your backdoor are pretty incredible - there's a reason people rave about anal play. Some folks use plugs as a warm-up act before other activities, while others just enjoy them on their own. Honestly, once you find the right fit, it can take your orgasm game to places you didn't know existed. Just don't expect fireworks on your first try - like learning to parallel park, it takes some practice.


Materials Matter More Than You Think

This is where things get serious for a hot minute. You wouldn't eat off a dirty plate, so don't put sketchy materials inside your body. We've seen too many horror stories from people who went cheap and paid the price later.


Silicone is your best mate here - it's soft, bendy, and cleans up beautifully. Glass might sound scary, but it's actually fantastic if you like things smooth and want to experiment with temperature (hello, ice cubes!). Stainless steel is for the adventurous types who want something with real weight behind it.


  • Silicone: Feels natural, comes in different firmness levels, perfect for newbies
  • Glass: Super smooth, great for temperature play, looks fancy on your nightstand
  • Stainless Steel: Heavy, intense sensations, makes you feel like you mean business
  • Hard pass: Anything jelly-like, PVC, or that weird rubber stuff that smells funky



Size Isn't Everything, But It's Pretty Important

Real talk - your eyes are probably bigger than your, well, you know. We've all been there, ordering something online that looked perfect in the photos only to have it arrive looking like it was designed for someone three times your size.

Starting small isn't admitting defeat, it's being smart. Think about it like this: you wouldn't jump straight into a black diamond ski run on your first day, would you? Most anal plugs have this clever tapered design that makes insertion way easier, plus that flared base that stops things from going on an unexpected adventure. Trust us, that flared base isn't optional - it's what keeps you out of awkward emergency room conversations.


Features That Actually Make a Difference

The world of best adult toys has gotten pretty fancy lately. Vibrating Butt Plug options can add this amazing buzzing sensation that some people absolutely swear by, though others find it distracting. It's like choosing between a massage with or without the fancy heated stones - both are great, just different.


Flexible plugs bend with your body, which is brilliant if you're planning to wear yours for a while or you're still figuring out what feels good. Rigid ones give you more focused sensations but can be less forgiving if you're not quite ready for them. Some of the high-tech options come with remote controls or phone apps, which can be fun for couples who want to spice things up from across the room.


Safety Tips That'll Save Your Bacon


A minimalist illustration of a person’s backside, emphasizing the importance of self-care and personal satisfaction through adult toys like anal plugs.

Right, let's talk about the stuff that isn't sexy but absolutely essential. Lube is your best friend here - and we mean proper amounts, not just a quick squirt. Think of it like buttering toast: you want good coverage, not just a tiny corner.

Your cleaning routine doesn't need to be surgical, but it should be thorough. Wash your anal plug before and after use with soap and warm water. If your body starts sending you "this doesn't feel right" signals, listen to it. Pain isn't part of the fun here. options act as gentle exercise equipment for these essential muscles.

  • That flared base we mentioned? Non-negotiable. Seriously.
  • Never go from back to front without cleaning first - that's just asking for trouble
  • More lube than you think you need, then add a bit more
  • If something hurts, stop. This should feel good, not like a medical procedure


What We'd Actually Recommend

For first-timers, grab something small and silicone. We're talking finger-sized, not "challenge accepted" sized. These usually run about 10-12cm long with a narrow tip that gradually gets wider. The goal is building confidence, not setting world records.

Once you've got the hang of things, Tail Butt Plugs can add a playful twist if you're into that sort of thing. They're basically regular plugs with decorative tails attached - think of them as the fancy dress costumes of the anal toy world. For the more experienced crowd, you might want something with more substance, different textures, or those vibrating features we talked about.


Shopping Smart Online

Buying intimate stuff online is brilliant for privacy, but you've got to be clever about where you shop. Look for New Zealand retailers who understand that discretion matters - nobody wants their neighbors knowing what's in their delivery boxes.

Customer reviews are gold, but remember everyone's built differently. What sends one person to the moon might leave another feeling meh. Check the return policy before you buy, and don't be shy about contacting customer service if you've got questions. Good retailers want you to be happy with your purchase, not dealing with buyer's remorse.


Your Burning Questions Answered

What size should a complete beginner start with?

About the width of your finger - seriously, start small and work your way up.

Is it safe to sleep with one in?

Quick power naps might be fine, but don't make it an all-night thing.

How long do these things last?

Good silicone ones can go for years if you treat them right.

What's the deal with anal beads versus plugs?

Beads move in and out, plugs stay put - different sensations entirely.

Do I really need special lube?

Yes, get the good stuff designed for anal play - your body will thank you.

Can these help with preparation for other activities?

Absolutely, they're fantastic training tools for working up to bigger things.

Are the vibrating ones worth the extra cost?

Depends on your preferences, but many people find the vibrations add a nice extra dimension.

How paranoid should I be about cleaning?

Thorough but not obsessive - warm water and mild soap does the trick perfectly.

A man tied up and ready to explore BDSM, showcasing the best sex toys for men who crave BDSM thrills
By Emma Hanover July 25, 2025
Unleash your BDSM desires with the best sex toys for men. Explore restraints, floggers, and more. Find quality gear for safe, intense pleasure. Shop now!
Best NZ sex toys for extreme pleasure, enhancing your intimate experience with high-quality adult to
By Emma Hanover July 24, 2025
Discover top-rated NZ sex toys for ultimate pleasure. From beginner-friendly to premium sex toy options. Shop discreetly online & experience the difference!
Why Buying Sex Toys for Men Online Is the Smartest and Most Discreet Choice
By Emma Hanover July 22, 2025
Buy sex toys for men online with discretion and convenience. Browse our huge selection, read honest reviews, and enjoy discreet shipping. Shop here today!
Why Investing in Female Adult Toys for Masturbation Is a Powerful Act of Self-Care
By Emma Hanover July 16, 2025
Self-love just got easier (and more fun!). This blog would help you discover the benefits of buying female adult toys. Discreet online shopping. Shop now!
Buying female adult toys can boost self-love and confidence, promoting sexual well-being.
By Emma Hanover July 10, 2025
Discover how female adult toys enhance self-love and confidence. Explore its amazing benefits, plus tips for choosing the right toys. Shop discreetly online!
Promotional banner featuring male adult toys with muscular man, highlighting premium sex toy for men
By Emma Hanover July 7, 2025
Discover the best male adult toys online. Explore diverse options, and shop discreetly. Find high-quality, body-safe toys to enhance your pleasure NOW!
A person is typing on a laptop next to a bunch of adult toys.
By Pentwater Connect July 2, 2025
Discover why buying adult toys online offers unmatched privacy, discreet packaging, secure billing & a comfortable, anonymous shopping experience.
How Adult Toys for Couples Can Spark Passion and Deepen Your Connection
By Emma Hanover June 17, 2025
Find the perfect adult toys for couples online. Discreet shipping, wide selection, and expert tips for a more passionate relationship. Shop now!
June 17, 2025
Unlock 7 insider tips for choosing the perfect adult toy online. Discover safe materials and amazing products at the best adult toy stores. Shop now!
By The Totally Adult Team May 6, 2025
Your friendly NZ guide to choosing your first adult sex toy! Explore vibrators, dildos & more online. Find quality adult toys with discreet shipping in New Zealand from Totally Adult, your trusted online adult shop. Free NZ shipping available for Kiwis.